/* This file is part of cpp-ethereum. cpp-ethereum is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or (at your option) any later version. cpp-ethereum is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the GNU General Public License for more details. You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License along with cpp-ethereum. If not, see . */ /** * @author Lefteris * @author Gav Wood * @date 2014 * Solidity command line interface. */ #include "CommandLineInterface.h" #ifdef _WIN32 // windows #include #define isatty _isatty #define fileno _fileno #else // unix #include #endif #include #include #include #include #include #include #include "solidity/BuildInfo.h" #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include #include using namespace std; namespace po = boost::program_options; namespace dev { namespace solidity { static string const g_argAbiStr = "abi"; static string const g_argSignatureHashes = "hashes"; static string const g_argGas = "gas"; static string const g_argAsmStr = "asm"; static string const g_argAsmJsonStr = "asm-json"; static string const g_argAstStr = "ast"; static string const g_argAstJson = "ast-json"; static string const g_argBinaryStr = "bin"; static string const g_argRuntimeBinaryStr = "bin-runtime"; static string const g_argCloneBinaryStr = "clone-bin"; static string const g_argOpcodesStr = "opcodes"; static string const g_argNatspecDevStr = "devdoc"; static string const g_argNatspecUserStr = "userdoc"; static string const g_argAddStandard = "add-std"; static string const g_stdinFileName = ""; /// Possible arguments to for --combined-json static set const g_combinedJsonArgs{ "bin", "bin-runtime", "clone-bin", "srcmap", "srcmap-runtime", "opcodes", "abi", "interface", "asm", "ast", "userdoc", "devdoc" }; static void version() { cout << "solc, the solidity compiler commandline interface" << endl << "Version: " << dev::solidity::VersionString << endl; exit(0); } static bool needsHumanTargetedStdout(po::variables_map const& _args) { if (_args.count(g_argGas)) return true; if (_args.count("output-dir")) return false; for (string const& arg: { g_argAbiStr, g_argSignatureHashes, g_argNatspecUserStr, g_argAstJson, g_argNatspecDevStr, g_argAsmStr, g_argAsmJsonStr, g_argOpcodesStr, g_argBinaryStr, g_argRuntimeBinaryStr, g_argCloneBinaryStr, string("formal") }) if (_args.count(arg)) return true; return false; } void CommandLineInterface::handleBinary(string const& _contract) { if (m_args.count(g_argBinaryStr)) { if (m_args.count("output-dir")) createFile(_contract + ".bin", m_compiler->object(_contract).toHex()); else { cout << "Binary: " << endl; cout << m_compiler->object(_contract).toHex() << endl; } } if (m_args.count(g_argCloneBinaryStr)) { if (m_args.count("output-dir")) createFile(_contract + ".clone_bin", m_compiler->cloneObject(_contract).toHex()); else { cout << "Clone Binary: " << endl; cout << m_compiler->cloneObject(_contract).toHex() << endl; } } if (m_args.count(g_argRuntimeBinaryStr)) { if (m_args.count("output-dir")) createFile(_contract + ".bin-runtime", m_compiler->runtimeObject(_contract).toHex()); else { cout << "Binary of the runtime part: " << endl; cout << m_compiler->runtimeObject(_contract).toHex() << endl; } } } void CommandLineInterface::handleOpcode(string const& _contract) { if (m_args.count("output-dir")) createFile(_contract + ".opcode", solidity::disassemble(m_compiler->object(_contract).bytecode)); else { cout << "Opcodes: " << endl; cout << solidity::disassemble(m_compiler->object(_contract).bytecode); cout << endl; } } void CommandLineInterface::handleBytecode(string const& _contract) { if (m_args.count(g_argOpcodesStr)) handleOpcode(_contract); if (m_args.count(g_argBinaryStr) || m_args.count(g_argCloneBinaryStr) || m_args.count(g_argRuntimeBinaryStr)) handleBinary(_contract); } void CommandLineInterface::handleSignatureHashes(string const& _contract) { if (!m_args.count(g_argSignatureHashes)) return; string out; for (auto const& it: m_compiler->contractDefinition(_contract).interfaceFunctions()) out += toHex(it.first.ref()) + ": " + it.second->externalSignature() + "\n"; if (m_args.count("output-dir")) createFile(_contract + ".signatures", out); else cout << "Function signatures: " << endl << out; } void CommandLineInterface::handleMeta(DocumentationType _type, string const& _contract) { std::string argName; std::string suffix; std::string title; switch(_type) { case DocumentationType::ABIInterface: argName = g_argAbiStr; suffix = ".abi"; title = "Contract JSON ABI"; break; case DocumentationType::NatspecUser: argName = g_argNatspecUserStr; suffix = ".docuser"; title = "User Documentation"; break; case DocumentationType::NatspecDev: argName = g_argNatspecDevStr; suffix = ".docdev"; title = "Developer Documentation"; break; default: // should never happen BOOST_THROW_EXCEPTION(InternalCompilerError() << errinfo_comment("Unknown documentation _type")); } if (m_args.count(argName)) { if (m_args.count("output-dir")) createFile(_contract + suffix, m_compiler->metadata(_contract, _type)); else { cout << title << endl; cout << m_compiler->metadata(_contract, _type) << endl; } } } void CommandLineInterface::handleGasEstimation(string const& _contract) { using Gas = GasEstimator::GasConsumption; if (!m_compiler->assemblyItems(_contract) && !m_compiler->runtimeAssemblyItems(_contract)) return; cout << "Gas estimation:" << endl; if (eth::AssemblyItems const* items = m_compiler->assemblyItems(_contract)) { Gas gas = GasEstimator::functionalEstimation(*items); u256 bytecodeSize(m_compiler->runtimeObject(_contract).bytecode.size()); cout << "construction:" << endl; cout << " " << gas << " + " << (bytecodeSize * eth::GasCosts::createDataGas) << " = "; gas += bytecodeSize * eth::GasCosts::createDataGas; cout << gas << endl; } if (eth::AssemblyItems const* items = m_compiler->runtimeAssemblyItems(_contract)) { ContractDefinition const& contract = m_compiler->contractDefinition(_contract); cout << "external:" << endl; for (auto it: contract.interfaceFunctions()) { string sig = it.second->externalSignature(); GasEstimator::GasConsumption gas = GasEstimator::functionalEstimation(*items, sig); cout << " " << sig << ":\t" << gas << endl; } if (contract.fallbackFunction()) { GasEstimator::GasConsumption gas = GasEstimator::functionalEstimation(*items, "INVALID"); cout << " fallback:\t" << gas << endl; } cout << "internal:" << endl; for (auto const& it: contract.definedFunctions()) { if (it->isPartOfExternalInterface() || it->isConstructor()) continue; size_t entry = m_compiler->functionEntryPoint(_contract, *it); GasEstimator::GasConsumption gas = GasEstimator::GasConsumption::infinite(); if (entry > 0) gas = GasEstimator::functionalEstimation(*items, entry, *it); FunctionType type(*it); cout << " " << it->name() << "("; auto paramTypes = type.parameterTypes(); for (auto it = paramTypes.begin(); it != paramTypes.end(); ++it) cout << (*it)->toString() << (it + 1 == paramTypes.end() ? "" : ","); cout << "):\t" << gas << endl; } } } void CommandLineInterface::handleFormal() { if (!m_args.count("formal")) return; if (m_args.count("output-dir")) createFile("solidity.mlw", m_compiler->formalTranslation()); else cout << "Formal version:" << endl << m_compiler->formalTranslation() << endl; } void CommandLineInterface::readInputFilesAndConfigureRemappings() { vector inputFiles; bool addStdin = false; if (!m_args.count("input-file")) addStdin = true; else for (string path: m_args["input-file"].as>()) { auto eq = find(path.begin(), path.end(), '='); if (eq != path.end()) path = string(eq + 1, path.end()); else if (path == "-") addStdin = true; else { auto infile = boost::filesystem::path(path); if (!boost::filesystem::exists(infile)) { cerr << "Skipping non existant input file \"" << infile << "\"" << endl; continue; } if (!boost::filesystem::is_regular_file(infile)) { cerr << "\"" << infile << "\" is not a valid file. Skipping" << endl; continue; } m_sourceCodes[infile.string()] = dev::contentsString(infile.string()); path = boost::filesystem::canonical(infile).string(); } m_allowedDirectories.push_back(boost::filesystem::path(path).remove_filename()); } if (addStdin) { string s; while (!cin.eof()) { getline(cin, s); m_sourceCodes[g_stdinFileName].append(s + '\n'); } } } bool CommandLineInterface::parseLibraryOption(string const& _input) { namespace fs = boost::filesystem; string data = fs::is_regular_file(_input) ? contentsString(_input) : _input; vector libraries; boost::split(libraries, data, boost::is_space() || boost::is_any_of(","), boost::token_compress_on); for (string const& lib: libraries) if (!lib.empty()) { auto colon = lib.find(':'); if (colon == string::npos) { cerr << "Colon separator missing in library address specifier \"" << lib << "\"" << endl; return false; } string libName(lib.begin(), lib.begin() + colon); string addrString(lib.begin() + colon + 1, lib.end()); boost::trim(libName); boost::trim(addrString); bytes binAddr = fromHex(addrString); h160 address(binAddr, h160::AlignRight); if (binAddr.size() > 20 || address == h160()) { cerr << "Invalid address for library \"" << libName << "\": " << addrString << endl; return false; } m_libraries[libName] = address; } return true; } void CommandLineInterface::createFile(string const& _fileName, string const& _data) { namespace fs = boost::filesystem; // create directory if not existent fs::path p(m_args.at("output-dir").as()); fs::create_directories(p); string pathName = (p / _fileName).string(); ofstream outFile(pathName); outFile << _data; if (!outFile) BOOST_THROW_EXCEPTION(FileError() << errinfo_comment("Could not write to file: " + pathName)); } bool CommandLineInterface::parseArguments(int _argc, char** _argv) { // Declare the supported options. po::options_description desc( R"(solc, the Solidity commandline compiler. Usage: solc [options] [input_file...] Compiles the given Solidity input files (or the standard input if none given or "-" is used as a file name) and outputs the components specified in the options at standard output or in files in the output directory, if specified. Example: solc --bin -o /tmp/solcoutput contract.sol Allowed options)", po::options_description::m_default_line_length, po::options_description::m_default_line_length - 23); desc.add_options() ("help", "Show help message and exit.") ("version", "Show version and exit.") ("optimize", "Enable bytecode optimizer.") ( "optimize-runs", po::value()->value_name("n")->default_value(200), "Estimated number of contract runs for optimizer tuning." ) (g_argAddStandard.c_str(), "Add standard contracts.") ( "libraries", po::value>()->value_name("libs"), "Direct string or file containing library addresses. Syntax: " ":
[, or whitespace] ...\n" "Address is interpreted as a hex string optionally prefixed by 0x." ) ( "output-dir,o", po::value()->value_name("path"), "If given, creates one file per component and contract/file at the specified directory." ) ( "combined-json", po::value()->value_name(boost::join(g_combinedJsonArgs, ",")), "Output a single json document containing the specified information." ) (g_argGas.c_str(), "Print an estimate of the maximal gas usage for each function.") ( "assemble", "Switch to assembly mode, ignoring all options and assumes input is assembly." ) ( "link", "Switch to linker mode, ignoring all options apart from --libraries " "and modify binaries in place." ); po::options_description outputComponents("Output Components"); outputComponents.add_options() (g_argAstStr.c_str(), "AST of all source files.") (g_argAstJson.c_str(), "AST of all source files in JSON format.") (g_argAsmStr.c_str(), "EVM assembly of the contracts.") (g_argAsmJsonStr.c_str(), "EVM assembly of the contracts in JSON format.") (g_argOpcodesStr.c_str(), "Opcodes of the contracts.") (g_argBinaryStr.c_str(), "Binary of the contracts in hex.") (g_argRuntimeBinaryStr.c_str(), "Binary of the runtime part of the contracts in hex.") (g_argCloneBinaryStr.c_str(), "Binary of the clone contracts in hex.") (g_argAbiStr.c_str(), "ABI specification of the contracts.") (g_argSignatureHashes.c_str(), "Function signature hashes of the contracts.") (g_argNatspecUserStr.c_str(), "Natspec user documentation of all contracts.") (g_argNatspecDevStr.c_str(), "Natspec developer documentation of all contracts.") ("formal", "Translated source suitable for formal analysis."); desc.add(outputComponents); po::options_description allOptions = desc; allOptions.add_options()("input-file", po::value>(), "input file"); // All positional options should be interpreted as input files po::positional_options_description filesPositions; filesPositions.add("input-file", -1); // parse the compiler arguments try { po::command_line_parser cmdLineParser(_argc, _argv); cmdLineParser.options(allOptions).positional(filesPositions).allow_unregistered(); po::store(cmdLineParser.run(), m_args); } catch (po::error const& _exception) { cerr << _exception.what() << endl; return false; } if (m_args.count("help") || (isatty(fileno(stdin)) && _argc == 1)) { cout << desc; return false; } if (m_args.count("version")) { version(); return false; } if (m_args.count("combined-json")) { vector requests; for (string const& item: boost::split(requests, m_args["combined-json"].as(), boost::is_any_of(","))) if (!g_combinedJsonArgs.count(item)) { cerr << "Invalid option to --combined-json: " << item << endl; return false; } } po::notify(m_args); return true; } bool CommandLineInterface::processInput() { readInputFilesAndConfigureRemappings(); if (m_args.count("libraries")) for (string const& library: m_args["libraries"].as>()) if (!parseLibraryOption(library)) return false; if (m_args.count("assemble")) { // switch to assembly mode m_onlyAssemble = true; return assemble(); } if (m_args.count("link")) { // switch to linker mode m_onlyLink = true; return link(); } CompilerStack::ReadFileCallback fileReader = [this](string const& _path) { auto path = boost::filesystem::path(_path); if (!boost::filesystem::exists(path)) return CompilerStack::ReadFileResult{false, "File not found."}; auto canonicalPath = boost::filesystem::canonical(path); bool isAllowed = false; for (auto const& allowedDir: m_allowedDirectories) { // If dir is a prefix of boostPath, we are fine. if ( std::distance(allowedDir.begin(), allowedDir.end()) <= std::distance(canonicalPath.begin(), canonicalPath.end()) && std::equal(allowedDir.begin(), allowedDir.end(), canonicalPath.begin()) ) { isAllowed = true; break; } } if (!isAllowed) return CompilerStack::ReadFileResult{false, "File outside of allowed directories."}; else if (!boost::filesystem::is_regular_file(canonicalPath)) return CompilerStack::ReadFileResult{false, "Not a valid file."}; else { auto contents = dev::contentsString(canonicalPath.string()); m_sourceCodes[path.string()] = contents; return CompilerStack::ReadFileResult{true, contents}; } }; m_compiler.reset(new CompilerStack(fileReader)); auto scannerFromSourceName = [&](string const& _sourceName) -> solidity::Scanner const& { return m_compiler->scanner(_sourceName); }; try { if (m_args.count("input-file")) m_compiler->setRemappings(m_args["input-file"].as>()); for (auto const& sourceCode: m_sourceCodes) m_compiler->addSource(sourceCode.first, sourceCode.second); // TODO: Perhaps we should not compile unless requested bool optimize = m_args.count("optimize") > 0; unsigned runs = m_args["optimize-runs"].as(); bool successful = m_compiler->compile(optimize, runs); if (successful) m_compiler->link(m_libraries); if (successful && m_args.count("formal")) if (!m_compiler->prepareFormalAnalysis()) successful = false; for (auto const& error: m_compiler->errors()) SourceReferenceFormatter::printExceptionInformation( cerr, *error, (error->type() == Error::Type::Warning) ? "Warning" : "Error", scannerFromSourceName ); if (!successful) return false; } catch (CompilerError const& _exception) { SourceReferenceFormatter::printExceptionInformation(cerr, _exception, "Compiler error", scannerFromSourceName); return false; } catch (InternalCompilerError const& _exception) { cerr << "Internal compiler error during compilation:" << endl << boost::diagnostic_information(_exception); return false; } catch (Error const& _error) { if (_error.type() == Error::Type::DocstringParsingError) cerr << "Documentation parsing error: " << *boost::get_error_info(_error) << endl; else SourceReferenceFormatter::printExceptionInformation(cerr, _error, _error.typeName(), scannerFromSourceName); return false; } catch (Exception const& _exception) { cerr << "Exception during compilation: " << boost::diagnostic_information(_exception) << endl; return false; } catch (...) { cerr << "Unknown exception during compilation." << endl; return false; } return true; } void CommandLineInterface::handleCombinedJSON() { if (!m_args.count("combined-json")) return; Json::Value output(Json::objectValue); output["version"] = ::dev::solidity::VersionString; set requests; boost::split(requests, m_args["combined-json"].as(), boost::is_any_of(",")); vector contracts = m_compiler->contractNames(); if (!contracts.empty()) output["contracts"] = Json::Value(Json::objectValue); for (string const& contractName: contracts) { Json::Value contractData(Json::objectValue); if (requests.count("abi")) contractData["abi"] = m_compiler->interface(contractName); if (requests.count("bin")) contractData["bin"] = m_compiler->object(contractName).toHex(); if (requests.count("bin-runtime")) contractData["bin-runtime"] = m_compiler->runtimeObject(contractName).toHex(); if (requests.count("clone-bin")) contractData["clone-bin"] = m_compiler->cloneObject(contractName).toHex(); if (requests.count("opcodes")) contractData["opcodes"] = solidity::disassemble(m_compiler->object(contractName).bytecode); if (requests.count("asm")) { ostringstream unused; contractData["asm"] = m_compiler->streamAssembly(unused, contractName, m_sourceCodes, true); } if (requests.count("srcmap")) { auto map = m_compiler->sourceMapping(contractName); contractData["srcmap"] = map ? *map : ""; } if (requests.count("srcmap-runtime")) { auto map = m_compiler->runtimeSourceMapping(contractName); contractData["srcmap-runtime"] = map ? *map : ""; } if (requests.count("devdoc")) contractData["devdoc"] = m_compiler->metadata(contractName, DocumentationType::NatspecDev); if (requests.count("userdoc")) contractData["userdoc"] = m_compiler->metadata(contractName, DocumentationType::NatspecUser); output["contracts"][contractName] = contractData; } bool needsSourceList = requests.count("ast") || requests.count("srcmap") || requests.count("srcmap-runtime"); if (needsSourceList) { // Indices into this array are used to abbreviate source names in source locations. output["sourceList"] = Json::Value(Json::arrayValue); for (auto const& source: m_compiler->sourceNames()) output["sourceList"].append(source); } if (requests.count("ast")) { output["sources"] = Json::Value(Json::objectValue); for (auto const& sourceCode: m_sourceCodes) { ASTJsonConverter converter(m_compiler->ast(sourceCode.first), m_compiler->sourceIndices()); output["sources"][sourceCode.first] = Json::Value(Json::objectValue); output["sources"][sourceCode.first]["AST"] = converter.json(); } } cout << Json::FastWriter().write(output) << endl; } void CommandLineInterface::handleAst(string const& _argStr) { string title; if (_argStr == g_argAstStr) title = "Syntax trees:"; else if (_argStr == g_argAstJson) title = "JSON AST:"; else BOOST_THROW_EXCEPTION(InternalCompilerError() << errinfo_comment("Illegal argStr for AST")); // do we need AST output? if (m_args.count(_argStr)) { vector asts; for (auto const& sourceCode: m_sourceCodes) asts.push_back(&m_compiler->ast(sourceCode.first)); map gasCosts; if (m_compiler->runtimeAssemblyItems()) gasCosts = GasEstimator::breakToStatementLevel( GasEstimator::structuralEstimation(*m_compiler->runtimeAssemblyItems(), asts), asts ); if (m_args.count("output-dir")) { for (auto const& sourceCode: m_sourceCodes) { stringstream data; string postfix = ""; if (_argStr == g_argAstStr) { ASTPrinter printer(m_compiler->ast(sourceCode.first), sourceCode.second); printer.print(data); } else { ASTJsonConverter converter(m_compiler->ast(sourceCode.first)); converter.print(data); postfix += "_json"; } boost::filesystem::path path(sourceCode.first); createFile(path.filename().string() + postfix + ".ast", data.str()); } } else { cout << title << endl << endl; for (auto const& sourceCode: m_sourceCodes) { cout << endl << "======= " << sourceCode.first << " =======" << endl; if (_argStr == g_argAstStr) { ASTPrinter printer( m_compiler->ast(sourceCode.first), sourceCode.second, gasCosts ); printer.print(cout); } else { ASTJsonConverter converter(m_compiler->ast(sourceCode.first)); converter.print(cout); } } } } } void CommandLineInterface::actOnInput() { if (m_onlyAssemble) outputAssembly(); else if (m_onlyLink) writeLinkedFiles(); else outputCompilationResults(); } bool CommandLineInterface::link() { // Map from how the libraries will be named inside the bytecode to their addresses. map librariesReplacements; int const placeholderSize = 40; // 20 bytes or 40 hex characters for (auto const& library: m_libraries) { string const& name = library.first; // Library placeholders are 40 hex digits (20 bytes) that start and end with '__'. // This leaves 36 characters for the library name, while too short library names are // padded on the right with '_' and too long names are truncated. string replacement = "__"; for (size_t i = 0; i < placeholderSize - 4; ++i) replacement.push_back(i < name.size() ? name[i] : '_'); replacement += "__"; librariesReplacements[replacement] = library.second; } for (auto& src: m_sourceCodes) { auto end = src.second.end(); for (auto it = src.second.begin(); it != end;) { while (it != end && *it != '_') ++it; if (it == end) break; if (end - it < placeholderSize) { cerr << "Error in binary object file " << src.first << " at position " << (end - src.second.begin()) << endl; return false; } string name(it, it + placeholderSize); if (librariesReplacements.count(name)) { string hexStr(toHex(librariesReplacements.at(name).asBytes())); copy(hexStr.begin(), hexStr.end(), it); } else cerr << "Reference \"" << name << "\" in file \"" << src.first << "\" still unresolved." << endl; it += placeholderSize; } } return true; } void CommandLineInterface::writeLinkedFiles() { for (auto const& src: m_sourceCodes) if (src.first == g_stdinFileName) cout << src.second << endl; else writeFile(src.first, src.second); } bool CommandLineInterface::assemble() { //@TODO later, we will use the convenience interface and should also remove the include above bool successful = true; map> scanners; for (auto const& src: m_sourceCodes) { auto scanner = make_shared(CharStream(src.second), src.first); scanners[src.first] = scanner; if (!m_assemblyStacks[src.first].parse(scanner)) successful = false; else //@TODO we should not just throw away the result here m_assemblyStacks[src.first].assemble(); } for (auto const& stack: m_assemblyStacks) for (auto const& error: stack.second.errors()) SourceReferenceFormatter::printExceptionInformation( cerr, *error, (error->type() == Error::Type::Warning) ? "Warning" : "Error", [&](string const& _source) -> Scanner const& { return *scanners.at(_source); } ); return successful; } void CommandLineInterface::outputAssembly() { for (auto const& src: m_sourceCodes) { cout << endl << "======= " << src.first << " =======" << endl; eth::Assembly assembly = m_assemblyStacks[src.first].assemble(); cout << assembly.assemble().toHex() << endl; assembly.stream(cout, "", m_sourceCodes); } } void CommandLineInterface::outputCompilationResults() { handleCombinedJSON(); // do we need AST output? handleAst(g_argAstStr); handleAst(g_argAstJson); vector contracts = m_compiler->contractNames(); for (string const& contract: contracts) { if (needsHumanTargetedStdout(m_args)) cout << endl << "======= " << contract << " =======" << endl; // do we need EVM assembly? if (m_args.count(g_argAsmStr) || m_args.count(g_argAsmJsonStr)) { if (m_args.count("output-dir")) { stringstream data; m_compiler->streamAssembly(data, contract, m_sourceCodes, m_args.count(g_argAsmJsonStr)); createFile(contract + (m_args.count(g_argAsmJsonStr) ? "_evm.json" : ".evm"), data.str()); } else { cout << "EVM assembly:" << endl; m_compiler->streamAssembly(cout, contract, m_sourceCodes, m_args.count(g_argAsmJsonStr)); } } if (m_args.count(g_argGas)) handleGasEstimation(contract); handleBytecode(contract); handleSignatureHashes(contract); handleMeta(DocumentationType::ABIInterface, contract); handleMeta(DocumentationType::NatspecDev, contract); handleMeta(DocumentationType::NatspecUser, contract); } // end of contracts iteration handleFormal(); } } }